Skip to content
2024 Spring

HISTORY OF RACISM AND ANTI - SEMITISM - HIS380/HIS580 Spring 2024


Course
William Eddleston
For information about registration please contact our admissions.

The course traces the development of racial prejudice and anti-Semitism, from their roots in the classical and mediaeval worlds to the rise of National Socialism in the early 20th century. Particular emphasis will be paid to the manner in which religious, cultural, linguistic and physical/biological forms of exclusion have overlapped and reinforced each other. It is one of the principal contentions of this course that National Socialism's exterminatory anti-Semitism is not merely a product of centuries of anti-Jewish prejudice; rather, racial anti-Semitism must be understood as something which evolved in close symbiosis with racial prejudices directed against Africans - slave and free - and colonial peoples from the early modern period, culminating in the historically-particular form of exterminatory racial anti-Semitism which formed the necessary precondition of the Holocaust.

Here is the course outline:

1. The History of Racism and Anti-Semitism - Introduction to Course

Feb 5

Introductory quiz; distribution of syllabus and explanation of course requirements; assignment of students into A, B, C, D & E reading and presentation groups. Following and as part of the introductory quiz, there will be an ungraded class discussion, talking about definitions of racism and anti-Semitism in light of both your own experience and what you have learned from the assigned readings for this first class. Reading: Kidd, Colin. The Forging of Races: 1-18; Ratansi, Ali. Racism: A Very Short Introduction: 25-44 & Beller, Stephen. Antisemitism: A Very Short Introduction: 1-11, 55-77. (Beller and Ratansi can be found in the Resources folder marked “Textbooks,” and Kidd can be found in the folder marked “General Materials.”) Assignments/deadlines: Introductory quiz and discussion of racism and anti-Semitism based on above readings.

2. Race and Race Prejudice in Classical Antiquity

Feb 12

This seminar is introduced by a presentation from the lecturer – “Xenophobia and Race Prejudice in Classical Antiquity” – which examines the nature of racial prejudice in the ancient Graeco-Roman world. Was there a pronounced prejudice against Africans in the Classical World? Did the Greek world “invent” racism in the modern sense? Did ancient pagan Judeophobia anticipate later “anti-Semitism?” Discussion Seminar 1 – Was There Racism in Classical Antiquity? – looks at the contrasting perspectives of Benjamin Isaac, Eric Gruen and Frank Snowden on the nature of racism in the classical world. Reading: Isaac, Benjamin. “Racism: A Rationalisation of Prejudice in Greece and Rome.” In Eliav-Feldon, Miriam, Benjamin Isaac & Joseph Ziegler, eds. The Origins of Racism in the West. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009: 32-57. Assignments/deadlines: This seminar is introduced by the lecturer’s presentation. Groups A, B, C, D & E need to read their assigned reading and come to class prepared to discuss them and exchange ideas after the lecturer’s presentation.

3. Jews and Others in the Christian Middle Ages

Feb 19

This seminar unit examines the rise of the ritual murder accusation and later related “Blood Libel” in Crusading Europe. It asks one of the fundamental methodological questions to be explored in this course: is it anachronistic to talk of “anti-Semitism” in the European Middle Ages and early modern period? There is a special focus on the theories of Gavin I. Langmuir and his redefinition of the term “anti-Semitism.” Reading: Langmuir, Gavin I. Toward a Definition of Antisemitism. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990: 197-209; 263-298. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 2, Group A - The Mediaeval Blood Libel. Group A – presentation; Groups B, C, D & E– reading and discussion. In addition to the seminar, there will be a lecturer presentation on the Bible and the use of biblical texts to justify anti-Judaism, anti-black racism and other forms of racial prejudice.

4. Race and Religion in the Early Modern World

Feb 26

Seminar 3 - Race and the Inquisition: Jews, Moors and the Limpieza de Sangre in Spain and the Spanish New World – focuses on the 15th-16th century Spanish ethnic and religious cauldron, out of which one of the first seemingly “modern” doctrines of race emerged. Topics explored include the question of early modern “ethnic cleansing,” and the subsequent export of distinctively Iberian notions of race to the colonial societies of the New World. Readings: Kamen, Henry. The Spanish Inquisition: An Historical Revision. New edition. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1997: 214-55; Bethencourt, Francisco. Racisms: From the Crusades to the Twentieth Century. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2013: 163-180 Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 3, Group B – Race and the Inquisition: Jews, Moors and the Limpieza de Sangre. Group C – presentation. Groups A, C, D & E – reading and discussion.

5. Slavery, Race and the Bible in the Early Modern World

Mar 4

Most historians of race and racism trace the origins of these doctrines in their modern form to the rise of the Atlantic slave trade in the 16th and 17th centuries. Students will watch and discuss the documentary “The Colour of Money,” the first part of the BBC’s documentary series Racism: A History (2007). The seminar will explore one of the fundamental questions in the study of racism; namely, is “racism” as we understand it (a system of institutionalised discrimination based upon the alleged biological inferiority of a particular group) the precondition or the product of the transatlantic slave systems of the early modern and modern periods? Reading: Barbara Jean Fields. "Slavery, Race and Ideology in the United States of America." New Left Review, Issue 181, May/June 1990: 95-118; Sweet, James H. “The Iberian Roots of American Racist Thought.” The William and Mary Quarterly, Third Series, 54, no. 1 (January 1, 1997): 143-166. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 4, Group C – Slavery or Racism: Which Came First? Group C – presentation; Groups A, B, D & E – reading and discussion.

6. From Voltaire to Hitler?: Did the Enlightenment Lead to the Holocaust?

Mar 11

Today’s seminar and student presentation examines the famous thesis of the late Polish Marxist sociologist Zygmunt Bauman, who saw genocide and Nazism as symptoms of the crisis of industrial modernity. Also examined will the work of the radical Foucauldian historian Detlev Peukert. The work of these “Voltaire to Hitler” theorists will be examined against the critiques of scholars like Dan Brown, Yehuda Bauer and Stephen Bronner. Reading: Bauman, Zygmunt. Modernity and the Holocaust. Cambridge and New York: Polity Press, 1989: 83-116; Stone, Dan. Histories of the Holocaust. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press, 2010: 113-59. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 5, Group D – From Voltaire to Hitler?: Did the Enlightenment Lead to the Holocaust? Group E – presentation; Groups A, B, C and E – reading and discussion.

7. Racism, Collective Memory and Film

Mar 18

Few films can claim to have had the cultural impact of D.W. Griffith's 1915 Birth of a Nation. The most popular film of the silent era, it embodied the mythology of the both the “Lost Cause” and “Dunning School” versions of the Civil War and Reconstruction. (Significantly, the most successful film of all time - Gone with the Wind (1939) - is similarly steeped in these mythologies.) The film led directly to the founding of the so-called "Second Ku Klux Klan," which at its peak in the mid-1920s boasted the allegiance of over six million Americans. Students will watch a screening of parts the second half - "Reconstruction" - half of the film. A discussion of the film in light of modern scholarship on the Civil War, Reconstruction and collective memory will follow. Reading: Lake, Marylin & Henry Reynolds. Drawing the Global Colour Line: White Men’s Countries and the International Challenge of Racial Equality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008: 49-74 + “The Second American Revolution: Historian Eric Foner on slavery, freedom and contemporary US politics” (Jacobin Magazine Online, August 2015) - https://www.jacobinmag.com/2015/03/eric-foner-interview-reconstruction-slavery/ + David W. Blight, “The Civil War isn’t Over,” The Atlantic Online - http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/04/the-civil-war-isnt-over/389847/ Assignments/deadlines: None for this class, save for the readings (above).

8. Race and Language: Gobineau and his Essai sur l’inégalité des races humaines

Apr 8

The revolt against the universal rationality of the Enlightenment saw the Romantic movement’s celebration of all that was early, primitive and unique. The German philosopher Johann Gottfried Herder hailed unique languages as the most fundamental expression of the Volkgeist of particular peoples. By the mid-19th century, linguistically-based concepts like “Aryan” and “Semite” were increasingly being conflated with physiological racial classifications like hair colour and skull shape. Gobineau’s work is a watershed in this shift. Seminar 6 focuses on one of the most important pioneers of European racism, Comte Joseph de Gobineau, and on his influence on other key racist thinkers: the composer Richard Wagner and Henry Hotze, the apologist for the Confederacy and associate of the American School of polygenesis. Reading Dreher, Robert E. “Arthur de Gobineau, an Intellectual Portrait.” University of Wisconsin PhD, 1970: Chapter III, pp. 59-169. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 6, Group E – Gobineau and the Inequality of the Human Races. Group A – presentation. Groups A, B, C and D – reading and discussion. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 6, Group E – Gobineau and the Inequality of the Human Races. Group A – presentation. Groups A, B, C and D – reading and discussion.

9. The Rise of the White Man’s Republic: Race and Slavery in Jacksonian America

Apr 15

Early nineteenth century America – a slave-owning society rapidly expanding into territories occupied by peoples deemed “racially inferior” – was to be the laboratory for ideas which would have a rapid a profound impact on the development of European racism. This seminar explores the connections between slavery, the growing popular belief in the concept of a “White Man’s Democracy,” and the rise of polygenism and biological racism in defence of slavery and “Manifest Destiny.” It builds upon the previous seminar on Gobineau, showing how the Comte’s theory of history was married with the physical racial theories – craniology and polygenesis – of the American School. There will be a lecturer presentation for this seminar, but no student presentation. Reading: Horsman, Reginald. Race and Manifest Destiny: The Origins of American Racial Anglo-Saxonism. New Ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1986: 98-157. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 7, Group A – A Science for Slavery? American Craniology and Polygenesis in Defence of Manifest Destiny and the “Peculiar Institution” – Group A – presentation. Groups B, C, D & E – reading and discussion.

10. Race, Empire and Evolution

Apr 22

When Hitler and Himmler articulated plans for the conquest and colonisation of the East, they drew explicit parallels and justifications from American westward expansion and British colonial policy in India. However, the connections between Nazi colonial practices in German South-West Africa in the early 20th century are far more direct. Students will watch and discuss the BBC documentary Racism: A History – Part 2: Fatal Impacts (2007). Seminar 8 will look at the crucial split in British anthropology in the 1860s between the anti-slavery, monogenist Ethnological Society of London – heir to the old Anti-Slavery and Aborigine’s Protection Societies - and the pro-slavery, pro- imperialist and polygenist Anthropological Society of London. This watershed event in the history of racial though is examined in the context of the American Civil War and Britain’s deepening imperial commitment. Reading: Lorimer, Douglas A. Colour, Class and the Victorians: English Attitudes to the Negro in the mid-Nineteenth Century. Leicester: Leicester University Press, 1978: 131-212. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 8, Group B – From ESL to ASL: Race, Empire and the American Civil War - Group C – presentation. Groups A, C, D and E – reading and discussion.

11. Nationalism, Racism and Anti-Semitism in Europe, 1871-1939

Apr 29

This class examines the closely related rise of the notion of an “Aryan” and a “Semite” race. From their origins as uncontroversial linguistic families, we will trace the way they became conflated with physiological racial concepts by the mid to late-nineteenth century. From Ernest Renan’s linguistics to the Houston Stewart Chamberlain’s “Aryan Christ,” through to the eclectic anthropometric racial studies of Eugen Fischer and the race mysticism of the Nazi Party’s racial ideologist Alfred Rosenberg, we trace the lineages of the creation of these fictive racial groups. Reading: Stone, Dan. Histories of the Holocaust. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2010: 160-202; Hutton, Christopher M. Race and the Third Reich: Linguistics, Racial Anthropology and Genetics in the Dialectic of Volk. London: Polity, 2005: 35-112. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 9, Group C – From Language to Race: The Making of the Aryan and Semite Races – presentation; Groups A, B, D and E – reading and discussion. Research Essays due. All research essays must be submitted online at the NEO Assignment “Research Essay” by 23.59/11.59 pm CET Sunday, April 28th.

12. Racism, Nordicism and Eugenics

May 6

This seminar examines the intersections between racism, nationalism and eugenics in both the United States and Europe in the period leading up to the First World War – and beyond. We will explore the way in which racist thinkers like Madison Grant and Vacher de Lapouge married the racial theories of Gobineau with eugenics, anti-Semitism and the defence of Jim Crow and immigration restriction. Reading: Spiro, Jonathan Peter. Defending the Master Race: Conservation, Eugenics and the Legacy of Madison Grant. Burlington: The University of Vermont Press, 2009: 143-166, 297-327; Hecht, Jennifer Michael. “Vacher de Lapouge and the Rise of Nazi Racial Science.” The Journal of the History of Ideas, Vol. 61. No. 2 (April, 2000): 285-304. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 10, Group D – Racism, Nordicism and Eugenics - Group D – presentation; Groups A, B, C and E – reading and discussion.

13. Towards the Final Solution – Nazism and Colonial Violence

May 13

The final lecture demonstrates how the racism of Hitler, Himmler, Rosenberg and their followers represented the coming together of several streams of racialist thinking: anti-Semitism, biological racialism, Social Darwinism, colonial racism and eugenics. The radicalising effects of the violence and social militarisation of World War I and the Russian Revolution – from which the theory of “Judaeo-Bolshevism” and The Protocols of the Elders of Zion forgery emerged – was an essential element in “the Nazi Synthesis.” Seminar 10 explores the components of Nazi racialism in more detail, with a particular focus on Nazi Lebensraum theories and their affinities with colonial racism and genocide. We will examine the debate over the connections between Nazi genocide and the Herero and Nama genocide perpetrated by the Second Reich in the early years of the 20th century – the so-called “Kaiser’s Holocaust.” Reading: Stone, Dan. Histories of the Holocaust. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2010: 203-244. Assignments/deadlines: Presentation Seminar 11, Group E – The Colonial Roots of Nazi Genocide. Group E – presentation; Groups A, B, C & D – reading and discussion.

14. The Denouement: The Final Solution, 1941-45

May 20

In 1978, the British production team that produced the acclaimed documentary series The World at War returned to their archives to compile a special programme on the Final Solution. The result was arguably the most harrowing and compelling Holocaust documentary of its length ever made. Jeremy Isaacs and his team interviewed many of the same survivors who were later to feature in Claude Lanzmann’s milestone documentary Shoah. Students will watch and discuss the second part of this documentary – The Final Solution – Part 2 (BBC, 1978). Reading: There are no set readings for the final class. An informal discussion and lecture tying the various threads of the course together. Assignments/deadlines: Final Reflection Papers due. Your Final Reflection Paper must be handed in to me in hard copy – in 12-point font and double-spaced – by the beginning of class at 11.30 am CET, Monday May 20th. In addition, a Word or PDF copy of the paper must also be uploaded to NEO LMS Turnitin assignment “Final Reflection Paper” by the same time and date.

Back to top